A new UWC study is calling for a culture-sensitive approach towards both traditional male circumcision and medical male circumcision to improve safety while preserving culture. Image: Fikelephi NdisileFor many South Africans, Traditional Male Circumcision (TMC) is more than a cultural ritual. It is an important rite of passage that shapes identity, teaches cultural values, and marks the transition from boyhood to manhood. However, cases of serious injuries and deaths among initiates have placed the practice under increasing public scrutiny, raising concerns about its safety and future.
Medical Male Circumcision (MMC), on the other hand, has been shown to offer important health benefits and reduce many of these risks, yet research suggests that many communities where TMC is deeply rooted remain reluctant to embrace MMC because they believe it does not carry the same cultural meaning, resulting in low uptake.
Now, a new review by the University of the Western Cape (UWC) examining the relationship between TMC and MMC calls for a balanced, culturally sensitive approach that recognises the value of both systems to improve safety while preserving the cultural traditions important to many South African communities.
The review, published in the African Journal of Religion, Philosophy and Culture (AJRPC), examined the impact of TMC on young men aged 18 to 25 in the Bizana district of the Eastern Cape. Lead researcher and UWC lecturer at the Faculty of Community and Health Sciences, Lindani Sthembele Maphumulo, and co-author, Saziso Cromwell Qwaka, explored the intersections and tensions between TMC and MMC through a decolonial and Afrocentric lens, placing African worldviews, cultural authority and indigenous knowledge at the centre of the discussion. They also explored the cultural importance of TMC and the role that government healthcare services can play in supporting safer circumcision practices.
Medical male circumcision offers important health benefits, yet it is resisted in communities as people believe it doesn’t carry the same cultural meaning. Image: MART PRODUCTION/PexelsThe researchers argue that although MMC has been widely promoted as an effective strategy to reduce the risk of HIV transmission, its campaigns have largely been shaped by Western biomedical perspectives that prioritise clinical efficiency and disease prevention. As a result, TMC is often viewed primarily through a health-risk lens, rather than being recognised as an important cultural institution with its own knowledge systems, values and social significance.
In contrast, TMC encompasses social, spiritual and moral dimensions that cannot be fully understood outside their cultural context. They found that TMC is much more than a medical procedure, but a significant cultural practice that shapes boys' identities and teaches them values as they transition into men, something that MMC does not, even though it offers important health benefits.
Young men who were traditionally circumcised reported that the teachings they’ve received during ceremonies made them feel more mature, responsible and less abusive. On the other hand, MMC was associated with stigma and discrimination among Xhosa initiates in the Eastern Cape, and was associated with immaturity, shame and embarrassment.
Lead researcher Lindani Maphumulo. Image: SuppliedThe study argues for a decolonised approach to male circumcision that recognises the coexistence of medical interventions with traditional practices, while privileging the voices, agency and lived experiences of African communities.
The researchers conclude that protecting both cultural traditions and the health of initiates should be the primary priority, arguing that integrating traditional and medical male circumcision requires mutual respect and stronger collaboration between traditional leaders, healthcare professionals and government. Such an approach would enable communities to retain ownership of their cultural practices while benefiting from biomedical safeguards that improve the safety of initiation.
"The future challenge involves synthesising these two approaches to ensure cultural preservation without compromising public health and safety standards. Government intervention, community education and cross-cultural dialogue will be key to addressing the health risks and fostering a more inclusive approach to male circumcision in the region,” researchers noted.
