Prof Nadera Shalhoub-Kevorkian was the keynote speaker at Beyond the Torture Chamber: Cartographies of Genocidal Terror. Image: Shelley Christians/UWC

What happens when torture can no longer be located within four walls, hidden from the world’s view? What if the conditions that prevent people from healing, finding safety, or sustaining everyday life become part of the violence itself? These difficult questions were all asked in the context of the ongoing genocidal violence taking place in Gaza. There were also questions at the heart of a public lecture, recently hosted at the University of the Western Cape (UWC), where Prof Nadera Shalhoub-Kevorkian challenged conventional understandings of torture by examining the experiences of Palestinians in Gaza.

Titled, Beyond the Torture Chamber: Cartographies of Genocidal Terror, the lecture was hosted by the Institute for Social and Health Sciences at the University of South Africa in collaboration with UWC’s Institute for Social Development. Prof Shalhoub-Kevorkian drew on testimonies and critical scholarship to ask how violence should be understood when it operates not only through identifiable acts against individuals, but through broader social, material, infrastructural and environmental conditions.

“Torture is not only what is done to the body, but the systematic withdrawal of the conditions through which the body might repair itself,” she said.

Her lecture examined this concept through the lens of access to healthcare and conditions affecting recovery, displacement, infrastructure and the environment. She argued that these interconnected conditions require scholars to consider torture beyond the traditional image of an isolated victim and identifiable perpetrator inside a particular physical space.

Discussing her conceptualisation of this broader landscape of violence, she said: “Torture is not a discrete act.”

Prof Shalhoub-Kevorkian shared the harrowing story of a Palestinian mother, Aisha, who gave birth to a baby boy, Marwaan, while displaced in Gaza. There was no hospital Aisha could go to, and she and her family moved repeatedly between displacement sites. Aisha said that she struggled to breastfeed and that obtaining infant formula became difficult and dangerous. Aisha described the experience in particularly powerful terms: “Marwan was born into torture. There was no food. There was no baby formula.” When the family did obtain formula, Aisha said the available type repeatedly changed. Prof Shalhoub-Kevorkian used this to discuss the importance of consistency in infant nutrition alongside access to clean water, safe preparation, healthcare and stable living conditions. According to Aisha's testimony, Marwan developed persistent health problems, and she feared that he might not survive his first year. Aisha told Prof Shalhoub-Kevorkian: “Every time they changed it (the baby formula), Marwan was tortured. We were all tortured.”

Responding to the lecture, Prof Ashraf Kagee of Stellenbosch University explored the psychological dimensions of its argument and the language through which suffering and trauma are understood. “Torture in Gaza is not a discrete act. In the same way that trauma is not an index event in this context, it’s not a single thing,” Prof Kagee said.

He argued that understanding sustained violence requires moving away from frameworks that interpret trauma solely as something resulting from a single event in the past. Where threatening conditions continue, he suggested, trauma itself cannot necessarily be understood as having ended. “If the Nakba is continuing and ongoing, and the genocide is the latest manifestation of this colonial oppression, then its trauma is not past but continuing,” Prof Kagee said.

His response also introduced the Palestinian concept of Sumud, commonly associated with steadfastness, as a way of thinking about survival and resistance. “If the purpose of genocide is erasure, then Sumud is the refusing of erasure,” he said.

For Prof Kagee, care itself could become significant under conditions of sustained violence. He described psychological and psychosocial support for people living through grief, bereavement and trauma as forms of steadfastness, particularly when such care affirms people's humanity and relationships with one another.

Dr Thandi Gamedze, from the Desmond Tutu Centre for Religion and Social Justice, was also part of the panel discussion and reminded everyone of a nurse named Ahmad that Prof Shalhoub-Kevorkian mentions in her paper. She said: “I'm thinking about his (Ahmad’s) story within the context of how infection and injury form part of this infrastructure of torture. Ahmad says, "Since the injury of my son and daughter, I have stopped knowing who is torturing us. The injury, the unending genocidal conditions, the lack of food, the lack of antibiotics, and I stop knowing who is infecting whom. Now the whole family suffers from bacterial infections, and there is no remedy.”

Dr Gamedze added, “And while, of course, it's not the same thing, I couldn't help but see a parallel between this state of injury and infection, whose cause and origin is no longer clear. Who is infecting whom? Who is torturing us? And the violence so deeply embedded within our post-apartheid, post-colonial society, in which these histories of colonial and apartheid violence have produced the material and psychological conditions to foreclose.”

The discussion extended beyond Gaza to questions about how academics, health professionals and institutions understand violence, oppression and recovery. Finally, it also resonated with UWC’s historical tradition of socially engaged scholarship and intellectual engagement with struggles against injustice.