Researchers have been urged to recognise communities and build genuine relationships with them when conducting research, rather than treating them solely as sources of information. Image: Pexels/Zen Chung

Researchers should stop using communities as resources but foster sustainable partnerships.

This troubling pattern was highlighted at the Khayelitsha and Eastern Substructure (KESS) Research Day.

In his keynote address, Prof Munya Saruchera labelled it “drive-through” community engagement, in which researchers entered areas to conduct surveys or extract information, produce reports, and move on to the next project.  He challenged researchers to go beyond simply collecting data and instead stay for the “MEaL” - monitoring, evaluation and learning.

The KESS Research Day is an annual event hosted by the University of the Western Cape (UWC)’s School of Public Health, KESS and the Western Cape Department of Health and Wellness. The event brought together academics, healthcare professionals and researchers to share findings, exchange knowledge and explore ways of strengthening healthcare services, particularly in underserved communities.

Prof Saruchera, Director of the Africa Centre for Inclusive Health Management, argued that meaningful and sustained community engagement requires genuine relationships, trust, time and continued involvement.

"When engagement becomes extractive in this nature, communities quickly learn that their role is simply to provide information and opinions, rather than being involved in shaping change," he said, noting that meaningful community engagement should not be something researchers do to people, but something they do with them.

Prof Munya Saruchera, Director of the Africa Centre for Inclusive Health Management at Stellenbosch University Image: Supplied

Prof Saruchera continued by noting that community organisations are often approached only when researchers submit funding applications or need to demonstrate community involvement to the funder. By then, important decisions about the research has already been made.

He challenged researchers to return their findings to communities before presenting them to university management, policymakers or funders. "How often do we go back with those very results?" he asked and called on researchers to involve community leaders from the beginning, compensate residents for their expertise and allow communities to help define the problems being investigated.

An example of a successful community-based partnership was illustrated by Prof Natalie Gordon, a senior lecturer in UWC’s Department of Oral Hygiene. Launched about a decade ago, the initiative brings together UWC's Faculty of Dentistry, the health department and non-profit organisation Ikamva Labantu. It integrates oral health education, dental screening and treatment into an existing training programme for early childhood development (ECD) educators. It reaches more than 100 educators who collectively work with 3000 to 4000 children every year.

What began as a community service initiative has evolved into a research collaboration, with a formal impact evaluation planned for the 2026 cohort. Prof Gordon highlighted the need for such interventions, citing research from the early 2000s showing that 77% of children aged four to five in the Western Cape had experienced tooth decay, with 72% having untreated decay. Among 15-year-olds, 80% had experienced decay and 75% of those were untreated.

Prof Natalie Gordon, a Senior Lecturer in UWC’s Department of Oral Hygiene. Image: Supplied

Prof Gordon believes the community model could be scaled up, demonstrating how existing community programmes can improve access to oral healthcare.

"We see ourselves as a resource to the organisation," she said, emphasising the importance of collaboration in achieving greater equity in healthcare, highlighting that oral health status is clear evidence of inequities across communities. "We all plan together. The research will be done as a collaboration," she said.

UWC PhD candidate Sweetness Kola presented another effective community partnership. She highlighted the role of young people in helping their peers access HIV prevention and sexual and reproductive healthcare. Her study examined a peer-led programme in which youth ambassadors were placed at 20 healthcare facilities across the Cape Metro to improve access to pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP), particularly among young women aged 15 to 24.

Her study among young women, aged 15-24, taking pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP), found that young people were more comfortable discussing sensitive health issues with ambassadors of a similar age who spoke their language - helping to build trust and address misconceptions about PrEP. But staff shortages, stigma, negative attitudes among healthcare workers and limited youth-friendly spaces posed challenges.

The abrupt withdrawal of funding also left some ambassadors facing financial hardship and depression, highlighting the vulnerability of community-based programmes without sustained support.

The examples presented at the Research Day reinforced the need for researchers and institutions to look beyond data collection and remain accountable to the communities whose experiences and participation make their work possible.