Lead researcher Lynn Bust, a PhD candidate at UWC’s School of Public Health. Image: SuppliedAccessing healthcare that recognises and supports gender identity remains a challenge for many transgender and gender-diverse people in South Africa. A new study by University of the Western Cape (UWC) researchers has revealed significant gaps between the healthcare services they need and those they actually receive.
Transgender and gender-diverse people have a gender identity that differs from the sex they were assigned at birth, and gender-diverse people may identify outside traditional male and female categories.
The research, published in the South African Medical Journal, found that while most transgender and gender-diverse people wanted access to gender-affirming healthcare, only a small number had received services such as hormone therapy, psychological support or surgery. Gender-affirming care refers to different forms of support that help people live in a way that reflects their gender identity. This includes changing their names, pronouns or appearance, updating their names on identity documents, and using non-medical practices such as breast binding or chest flattening for transgender and gender-diverse people assigned female at birth, or tucking for those assigned male at birth.
The study, led by the Desmond Tutu HIV Centre at the University of Cape Town (UCT), surveyed 150 transgender and gender-diverse people in the Western Cape and Eastern Cape to understand their experiences of accessing healthcare, including HIV prevention and treatment services.
Existing research shows that transgender and gender-diverse people in South Africa face higher rates of HIV, sexually transmitted infections, tuberculosis, mental health problems and substance abuse than the general population. These health challenges are often made worse by the violence and discrimination they experience, highlighting the need for healthcare services that recognise their identities and address their specific health needs.
The latest findings show that among participants who did not receive medical gender-affirming care, about 77% were in need of psychosocial support, and nearly 7 in 10 wanted hormone therapy.
Although almost all participants (98.7%) had socially transitioned - meaning they had made changes such as adopting a different name, clothing or gender expression - only 4% had legally changed their gender details on identity documents. More than eight in ten (84.7%) had used non-medical practices, such as padding or tucking.
Although almost all participants (99.3%) had been tested for HIV, 34.2% of transgender and gender-diverse people assigned male at birth reported living with HIV, compared with only 7.9% of transgender and gender-diverse people assigned female at birth. Uptake of HIV prevention medication (PrEP) was low, at 30.4% and 5.7% respectively, while 78% of participants living with HIV were receiving antiretroviral treatment.
Lead researcher Lynn Bust, a PhD candidate at UWC’s School of Public Health and LGBT+ Research Programme Manager at the UCT-based Desmond Tutu Health Foundation, and co-authors, noted the findings revealed a significant gap between the gender-affirming healthcare and legal services that transgender and gender-diverse people need and what they can actually access. Other researchers include Bust’s colleagues Dr Richard Kaplan, Savuka Abongile Matyila, Olivia Welte, Nonkozi Xaba and Zimbini Zintwana, as well as UWC researchers Dr Michelle de Jong and Prof Asha George from the School of Public Health.
The researchers called for urgent improvements to ensure that gender-affirming care and HIV services are accessible and provided as part of an inclusive healthcare system across South Africa, warning that the lack of access to gender-affirming care “has substantial implications for mental health outcomes for transgender diverse people”. They called for greater collaboration between healthcare providers, government health departments, legal institutions and transgender communities to improve access to these services.
“The public health sector is best suited to provide this care in an affordable and sustainable manner,” they noted.
