South African courtrooms aren’t immune to the positive and negative impacts of Artificial Intelligence (AI) - be it from the witness stand to the legal counsel on both sides of the room. As recently as August 2026, an Acting Judge made headlines after being forced to explain how AI hallucinations were part of their judgment in the Johannesburg High Court.
This is an issue which University of the Western Cape (UWC) lecturer in the Department of Private Law, Mohamed Hoosain Sungay, tackled head-on at the recent 2026 Centre for Innovative Education and Communication Technologies (CIECT) AI Colloquium.
Addressing delegates at the colloquium, Sungay explored how generative AI is redefining legal research, education and practice. Drawing on his ongoing research, international engagements and faculty-level AI initiatives, Sungay argued that legal educators should move beyond resistance and prepare students for an AI-integrated future.
He described AI as the “new Google”, noting how quickly it had become embedded in everyday life: “That’s the paradigm shift,” he said. “At primary school level, learners are using ChatGPT. What are our university students doing? The same. What are our legal practitioners doing? The same.”
Generative AI is transforming how legal information is accessed and analysed, while placing greater emphasis on verification and critical thinking. Image: SuppliedRather than attempting to prohibit the use of AI, Sungay argued that universities should focus on teaching responsible engagement with these technologies. “Banning AI tools, in my opinion, is futile,” he said.
“Because in the real world, they’re going to use it either way.”
He emphasised that the real challenge lay in equipping students with the critical thinking skills needed to evaluate and verify AI-generated information. In the legal profession, errors arising from unverified AI outputs could have serious consequences, including fictitious case law, fabricated citations and breaches of professional conduct standards.
Central to Sungay’s argument was the principle of accountability. “Hundred percent student ownership,” he said. “Whatever they are submitting is theirs.”
He explained that the UWC Faculty of Law had adopted a Traffic Light Policy to guide the use of AI in academic work. The policy distinguishes between permitted, scaffolded and prohibited uses of AI, while encouraging disciplined engagement rather than blanket restrictions.
Sungay also highlighted the importance of oral assessment and source verification, arguing that students should be able to defend and explain their work.
“When you start a research paper, when you start writing something, by the time you come to the end of it, you should be able to speak about it. You should be able to interact with it.”
A key theme of the presentation is that expertise remained indispensable, even in an AI-enabled environment.
“The expert in the field must be the first line of defence,” Sungay said. “If someone sees something that’s written, something that’s submitted, you should be able to tell if it’s reliable because you are the expert in your field. This is also why rigorous teaching and research supervision are essential to developing law graduates into true experts, ensuring they do not outsource their human capacity for critical thought to inherently biased algorithms.”
The presentation concluded with a four-phase roadmap for the Faculty of Law: implementing AI policy guidelines, embedding mandatory source verification, introducing oral defences where possible, and ultimately producing graduates equipped for modern legal practice.
For Sungay, the objective is not merely technological adoption, but preparing future lawyers to navigate an increasingly AI-driven world ethically, critically and responsibly.
“Let’s build an AI-ready future for legal education together,” he said.
You can watch the full presentation HERE.
